2026-11-27 · 3 min read · Manteca
What Happens When You Get Multiple Offers on Your Manteca Home?

Overview
More than one offer feels like good news, and it is. Then the questions start. Which one do I take? What if I pick wrong? What if a better one comes tomorrow?
The highest price isn't always the best offer. Here's an example that shows why.
Two offers on the same house
This is a made-up example with round numbers, to show how I compare offers.
Offer A: $610,000
- FHA loan, buyer putting about 3.5% down
- Asks you to pay $15,000 of the buyer's closing costs
- Inspection, appraisal and loan contingencies
- Close in 45 days
Offer B: $600,000
- Conventional loan, buyer putting 20% down
- No help with closing costs
- Inspection and loan contingencies
- Close in 30 days
At first glance, A is $10,000 more. But look closer.
- The money you keep. Take away the $15,000 in closing costs and Offer A puts about $5,000 less in your pocket than Offer B, before anything else.
- The appraisal. If the house appraises under $610,000, Offer A's buyer has very little cash to cover the gap, so the price may have to come down.
- The timeline. Offer B closes two weeks sooner. If you're buying your next home, that can matter a lot.
In this example, Offer B is the stronger offer, even though it's lower.
What I look at in every offer
- The net. What you walk away with after costs, not just the price.
- The buyer's loan. Type of loan, size of the down payment, and a pre-approval from a lender I can actually call.
- The contingencies. How many, and how long each one lasts.
- The closing date. Does it fit your move?
- Anything extra they're asking for. A rent-back, an appliance, a repair.
Three ways to respond
1. Accept the best one. If one offer clearly stands out, accept it and keep things moving.
2. Counter one. Pick the offer you like most and counter it to fix the parts that don't work for you, like the closing date or the closing costs.
3. Ask everyone to improve. In California, a seller can send a counter offer to more than one buyer at the same time and ask each for their best terms. It's done with a specific form, and it has rules about who's bound to what and when. I walk my sellers through it line by line.
Each one has a trade-off. Asking everyone to improve can bring a better price, and it can also push a good buyer to walk away. That's a conversation we'd have before you decide.
Choosing without regret
I hold the Real Estate Negotiation Expert designation, and in my experience the sellers who feel best afterward are the ones who chose the offer most likely to close. The biggest number on paper only counts if it makes it to the finish line.
For the case where only one offer comes in, read Should You Accept the First Offer on Your Manteca Home?
Your next step
If you're listing soon, we'll talk through how we'd handle more than one offer before the sign goes up, so you're not deciding in a rush. Call or text me.
I'm Carolyn Cardoza, a Broker Associate and REALTOR® with Realty 1 Team in Manteca. If you would like to talk it through, contact me. You can also read more about selling your home or how I sell a home.